Monday, May 25, 2015

Not-so-Special Program for the Arts

Some years ago, ca. early 2000's, every summer, I would get invited by the National Commission for Culture and the Arts to help facilitate a theater workshop for teachers from all over the country. They were members of the faculty of the Department of Education's Special Program for the Arts, and I would usually various classes on theater: Acting, Directing, Stage Management, Technical Direction, etc.

A lot of the teachers assigned to this special program were former P.E. teachers, and for some of the participants in that workshop with whom I continued to work with outside the workshop, it was inspiring to see them grow into their new tasks: help mold their students into the country's future artists and culture bearers. Such a program used to only be available at the Makiling High School for the Arts, and having the privilege of knowing some of the school's alumni: Raymond Red, Shamaine Centenera-Buencamino, Soliman Cruz, to name a few, I was really excited by the idea that the Department of Education has expanded the program to pilots schools all over the country.

When the opportunity for one of our children to be in the program at the Baguio City National High School (BCNHS) presented itself, we grabbed it. Our daughter has been taking ballet lessons and was really showing some potential. She took the written entrance examination and passed it, and the next couple of weeks were spent preparing her for the next step: a dance audition. She passed that too.

On her first year, as part of the first batch to be in the recently implemented K-12 program, much of their time was spent learning indigenous dances along with some traditional folk dances. Our daughter would come home excited to show us a new movement she learned and the story behind each step.

They got to experience performing infront of audiences too as their group would usually be invited to showcase a dance or two at various functions within and outside the school. I was already thinking of how much farther she can get in the field of the performing arts when she gets to college. I personally knew some of the first alumni of the BCNHS Special Program for the Arts and was immensely impressed by their talents. I worked with some of them when I had  a brief stint as an artist-in-residence at the University of Baguio (2005-06) and they delivered like professionals in each of the productions we staged.

From the early to the mid-2000's, Baguio City National High School was already slowly evolving into one of the city's arts and culture destinations - then, they regularly staged exhibits, plays, dance and musical performances that showcased amazing young talents. But in recent years, that stopped.

A couple of months ago, some of these alumni, most of whom have pursued more lucrative careers in other fields yet maintained their interest in the arts, while others actually started careers in various institutions engaged in different fields of creative expression, invited me to do a talk for this year's graduating batch. They were particularly concerned about the last few batches' apparent disinterest in pursuing careers in the arts.They were simply uninspired.

A new person was has been installed to head the SPA program of the school and one of her first directives was to trim down the "specialization time," or the time the young artists spent working on their craft, from two hours per day to just an hour. As a theater artist myself, I can't imagine what can be accomplished within just an hour. For theater, warm up and vocalization exercises already take up to 15 minutes leaving only 35-40 minutes for rehearsals or acting exercises to allow for at least 5-10 minutes for the students to cool down and prepare to go to their respective academic classes. It's basically the same with dance. Clearly, the new head has no real experience nor knowledge about the performing arts, or perhaps even the arts in general.

And then we received information that all the current mentors/advisers of all the specializations - dance, theater, musical, literary, visual and media arts were being replaced, mostly by MAPEH teachers. The current mentors have undergone several workshops, training sessions under different institutions through the years, and now they will be replaced by Music, Arts, Physical Education and Health teachers most of whom received their education through textbooks. The reason for the replacement isn't clear, but I'm almost certain that politics isn't totally out of the equation here.

Given the above circumstances, we now believe that the program may just do more harm than good as far as the children's potential creative talents are concerned so we decided to pull our daughter out of the program.

A bureaucratic approach to the program is what's slowly killing it. With Master's Degrees and Ph.D.'s being a dime a dozen these days, people may be given such lofty positions in the government bureaucracy, including public schools, on the basis of their years in service (which do not necessarily translate to wisdom/knowledge or actual skills) and 100% attendance in their post-graduate studies.

Sayang, is the only word I can think of. The Baguio City National High School's Special Program for the Arts held so much promise. But right now, it's just not special anymore.







 

16 comments:

  1. I graduated 2010 from visual arts. We were the last batch that sir soliven taught. I heard that sining pambansa was cut ever since the second one. :/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And just learned too that the band has now been sort of excluded from the program altogether. Really sad the way the arts is being taken for granted not just in BCNHS actually but in our city.

      Delete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. mentors are replaced by mapeh teachers? most of them are mapeh teachers already eversince, there's only 2-3 i think who are not mapeh.

    "Music, Arts, Physical Education and Health teachers most of whom received their education through textbooks" I'm sorry but this is not true.
    I'm a math teacher and i can say that from all the subjects, mapeh majors are the ones having tough hands-on activities during their college years. that's based from my experience. they are credible to teach SPA simply because they are MUSIC, ARTS, PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND HEALTH teachers. Though its true that the old mentors are very trained and skilled already in handling SPA, but that does not mean that a new mentor can't do the same but then of course there will be a big difference and its a difficult situation between the mentor and the student.

    Mentors/heads are changed because of bad issues,certain circumstances, or retirement. We cannot do anything about that if it's what the school needs to do in order to maintain the school and the mentor's reputation.

    Well, it was not good that the specia time will become 1 hour. It's not enough. I'm a graduate of SPA too, visual arts, and in some activities 1 hour is just preparation time.



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. Don't be sorry, you are of course entitled to your own opinion. I do understand that MAPEH teachers of course go through some hands on training in various subjects, but that cannot compare to the training that the experienced mentors have undergone through the years - take for example, the case of theater arts. As I've mentioned, I have been involved in various workshops for SPA teachers and in the case of theater, the wisdom they get from teachers and textbooks cannot be compared to what they get from the likes of Nanding Josef, veteran theater director/actor, who's just one of the many artists tapped to train SPA teachers. I know for a fact that for at least a couple of summer training sessions, National Artist Ramon Santos himself was one of the workshop facilitators. Imagine the kind of wisdom that these artists pass on to the teachers and in turn to their students.

      The replacement was abrupt, a result of politics and not of genuine concern for the students or the program. The transition could've been above suspicion if done properly, having the candidate mentors to undergo proper training first before being placed in such positions.

      Delete
  4. I think the pioneer mentors are really great in their craft. I am from batch 3 of SPA (batch 2006) theater. I didn't know things really changed over the years. I hope they can do something about this.Based from my experience, our specialization time before is already compressed. We only have 2 hours to finish everything and cutting it to 1 hour will be worse. How can you rehearse a 45 minute one act play in 1 hour? It will take you around 20 minutes to warm up.
    Though I'm not that informed right now, I can say that all our teachers before from different specializations are really qualified, if not over qualified. Being a teacher in SPA is not just about educational qualifications but also passion towards arts.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is bad. Hopefully the school will realize what they have done to the "REAL ARTISTS" of tomorrow. Please ! Take an act on this issue. Don't take this against me but the school is known for such talented kids. Pursue arts. Appreciate arts. Embrace arts.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "Abrupt replacement of mentors who do not have time to be trained" - This is very bad, what are the admin officials thinking! What degree of competence and wisdom will the new mentors share or guide their students. If this action is due to politics, shame on them! They are not thinking about the plight of their students but only their selfish vested interests!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anong nangyayari sa City High? Wala na ang dati nitong tatak, yung pagkakaroon ng concern sa mga mag-aaral hindi pulitika at paramihan ng certificates. Calling the principal, sana pakitingnan niyo po ito.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Let's not think negative about this issue. The old mentors really are very good mentors, but if they need to go out of SPA then let's give the new mentors a chance to show what they've got. They will never equal the old mentors when it comes to talents, skills or training but for sure they have something Special to share too. We're talking about talents here, each one of us has his/her own unique talent. We may be both dancers, painters, actors, singers, etc. but still we're different. The same to the mentors. SPA can't have the same mentor forever. We have to adopt to the change, specially now that the world changes very fast. Training, skills and talents grow overtime if you practice.

    Yes, i agree that the future mentors should have the proper training first, but then sometimes, specially in public schools, that can't be the case. There's a lot of changes going on in deped, and schools can't do anything but to adopt that change.

    If you're a professional, we should know that even if you have lots of certificates from different training and seminar-workshops, sometimes its useless. Why? Simply because real training come from the real experiences we encounter from the real world. We should also know that its difficult to find good training or seminars. So sometimes the only training a person gets is his/her real life experiences.

    So instead of arguing that this step of the school isn't good, why don't we help them to make it better? We can help by simply informing them of trainings/seminars that can enhance their skills as mentors. We are the Alumni of SPA. If before our mentors give as lots of opportunities to help us enhance our skills, why don't we give the SPA mentors too the same opportunity? Now that their are a lot of SPA graduates and SPA professionals out there who knows a lot of different and qualified people who can train new mentors of SPA. Or us alumni ourselves.

    Let us see what will happen first before we judge them, if it turns out good then let's help make it better. If it turns out bad, then still let's help them make it good. Who knows, maybe the future mentors are also alumni of SPA? As an SPA alumni can you say that you cannot do what you're mentors did? Can you say that you will never do better than them if our mentors themselves before knew that their students are very good, and some even better than them?

    No one is equal in this world, some are better, some are worse, but everybody has that something special to share.

    ReplyDelete
  9. sayang naman, yun pamandin ang funnest part of being in high school ko before

    ReplyDelete
  10. WELCOME TO SPA WHERE ALL SKILLED FREAKING NINJAS ARE RECRUITED IN ONE PROGRAM.IT IS ALSO WHERE OTHER ANTAGONIST STUDENTS WILL TRY TO TERMINATE YOU EVERYTIME U USE YOUR SPA JACKET IT IS ALSO A PROGRAM WHERE TEACHERS WILL COMPARE YOU ON ANOTHER CLASS AND ANOTHER PROGRAM.THIS IS A LONELY PROGRAM WHERE URE FRIENDS ARE ONLY SPA AND NOW ITS BEING SEPARATED BECAUSE OF COMMENTERS ON THIS BLOG WHICH SEPARATED OTHER SPECIAS IN THE CLASSES WHICH BULLIES THEM EVERYDAY AND TEACHERS KEEPS SAYING "I DID NOT EXPECT U WERE AN SPA" THIS BLOG MADE A BIG MESS THIS MESSAGE IS A GHOST WHERE KEEPS TELLING WE WILL ALWAYS BE LONELY.........YES WE KNOW WE ARE LONELY ........WE ARE SPA NAH JUST KIDDIN DO ANYTHING U WANT WE MOVE ON EVERYTIME SINCE STUDENTS HERE GETS KICKED OUT AFTER THEYRE DEAD (WE ARE ALL DEAD IN SPA)

    ReplyDelete
  11. In fairness... http://thereforeiam-kma.blogspot.com/2015/06/in-fairness-to-mapeh-teachers.html

    ReplyDelete
  12. My mother is (or was) an SPA teacher of BCNHS, until she decided to give up her post. She has had training for the specialization she taught. At first she was so fired up in teaching the next generation of artists. But batches came and went and her passion just waned. Believe me, I became one of her students myself. I remember my mother lamenting about the more recent batches of SPA students. Before, students did arts because they were inspired to do so. They LOVED art, and they perfected their craft by working hard. And when they did not do well in their academic subjects, they are given ultimatums that if they do not balance their academics and their arts, they'd be kicked out of the special program. It is, after all, a special program for a reason. One of my mother's students was a brilliant, brilliant artist. In fact, he is a famous artist today (I will not name him). But he did not do well in his academics. The SPA Head gave him an ultimatum, and that student worked hard to balance his subjects and his art. And he made it. The SPA was full of students who worked hard at studying while creating art. But nowadays, and my mother would tell me this, whenever she interviews upcoming SPA students to the specialization, she's disappointed with their motives. She would ask, "Why do you want to be a part of the SPA?" And the student would answer, "To get a stipend." And the worst part of the SPA system today is that whenever a student is failing an academic subject, teachers are compelled to just give them a passing grade because SOMEONE said that SPA students should not get failing grades. I am a testimony to this. Kapag may failed subject ka, tanggal ka na sa SPA o dapat bigyan ka pa ng isang chance to redeem yourself, and if you still failed, kicked out ka na. In my third year, I failed Chemistry. My Chemistry teacher told me I had failed the subject. That would merit me an ultimatum or a "kicking-out" of the SPA (because the SPA should keep its high standards), but when I received my report card, there was an 85 for my grade. My teacher would later admit she changed it because I was an SPA student. And I lost respect for myself. Where is the integrity? But many SPA students abuse this now. That just because they are SPA students, they are entitled to passing grades and do not need to work hard anymore. They are proud of being SPA students when even a regular student works harder than them. It's very, very, frustrating. The stipend and the grading system. No wonder there is disillusionment even in the faculty of arts.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This is a sad news...:( I Honestly feel sorry for those students who are left and would hopefully develop their skills more through the help of SPECIAL PROGRAM FOR THE ARTS...I remember when i was in Theater before, it was really an inspiring experience for me because not only that you feel special but because ..you create special things/art. But in this case, I hope the heads get to see how important a 2 hours of training is for the Artist to mold their talents. PLEASE SAVE THE FUTURE TALENTS!!!

    ReplyDelete